From: Identifying signals of memory from observations of animal movements
Question | Biological example | Method | Caveats, challenges, limitations | Implementation parameters or choices |
---|---|---|---|---|
Are animals more likely to visit areas that are more familiar to them? | Feral hogs primarily rely on recent experiences when making night time foraging decisions [76]. | Occurrence Distribution (OD) | The effects of unmodeled environmental drivers may be wrongly attributed to memory and vice versa [79]. | Time window for measuring past space use. Length of burn-in periods (how much early positional data to sacrifice to estimate the familiarity predictor?) |
Do animals prefer to visit areas they have not visited recently? (and if so, is there an optimal return time based on foraging or predation experience?) | Predators like wolves and brown bears delay returning to previously visited kill sites so that prey numbers may rebound to normal levels [45, 92]. | Time Since Last Visit (TSLV) | The effects of unmodeled environmental drivers may be wrongly attributed to memory and vice versa [79]. TSLV may be relatively homogeneous within an animal’s movement kernel. | “Patch” size (what is the typical spatial grain of the animal’s cognitive map?) Length of burn-in periods (how much early positional data to sacrifice to estimate the familiarity predictor?) |
Do migratory animals use consistent migration routes to return to the same seasonal ranges each year? | Mule deer (Odocoileus hemionus) have been shown to use the exact same migration routes and seasonal ranges, likely relying on their memory of those spatial locations to help them navigate [67]. | Distance and directional bias toward previously used areas across large spatial scales | The effects of unmodeled environmental drivers and social cues may be wrongly attributed to memory and vice versa [79]. | Whether to use angular covariates or distance-to covariates. Time window for measuring past space use. |